WAERMER

This page contains automatically translated content.

Heat Transition of the Urban Building Stock by Interactive Decision Space Analysis

Achieving German climate protection targets by 2030 requires a significant increase of renewable energy for heat provision in buildings as well as strong incentives for energetic renovation. The former can be achieved by switching to heat pumps as well as extensions of thermal heating grids fed by a high proportion of renewable energies. The transition requires high investments by building owners which need to align with plans for the local energy infrastructure. Obstacles and retentions need to be addressed to operate thermal grids effectively and cost efficiently.

Local infrastructure such as thermal grids and preferences as well as the scope of action of building owners need to align for sustainable heat provision.

In­te­gra­ti­on of Planning Tools

The project WAERMER shall apply a methodical integration of energy system optimisation on an urban level and agent-based modelling of individual investment behaviour including preferences and scope of action. It shall help identify the requirements for a successful transition of heat provision in the urban building stock towards CO2-neutrality. Building owners are surveyed about relevant factors of their investment decision making. In an iterative process, measures to incentivise individual investments can be developed and simulated as well as required adaptations to the technical energy system identified. The agent-based modelling explicitly considers the influence of energy consultants and craftspeople concerning their changing knowledge and recommendations.

Interative exploration by multi-criteria-analysis and agent-based simulation

Stakeholders in Kiel

The participatory approach of the decision making process is important. Stakeholders get informed by decision workshops and initially state their criteria and formal as well as economic boundary conditions. Results of the planning tools are played back to stakeholders to receive their evaluation. For the first application the state capital Kiel is involved.

Key Facts

FundingFederal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy
Period08/2022 - 02/2026
PartnersFraunhofer Institute for Energy Economics and Energy System Technology (FhG IEE); Uni Kassel, Centre for Environmental Systems Research (CESR); Landeshauptstadt Kiel (LHK)
StaffDr. Sascha Holzhauer, Dr. Friedrich Krebs, Ivan Digel, Alwina Kaiser

Structure

Structure of project WAERMER

The structure of the work packages in the project WAERMER is based on the tools to be developed (design of techno-economically consistent energy systems in AP3 and agent-based modelling in AP4). Furthermore, AP2 empirically examines the individual heating technology-related decisions made by homeowners. The analysis of the relevant actors and the study area in AP1, as well as the implementation of the decision workshops and the dissemination of the results in AP5, frame the work. The partners involved are colour-coded in the figure.

Contact persons

Coordination Friedrich Krebs (University of Kassel) fkrebs@uni-kassel.de
Decision Workshops Marlen Schurig (FhG IEE) marlen.schurig@iee.fraunhofer.de
Dialogtool Alwina Kaiser (University of Kassel) Alwina.Kaiser@uni-kassel.de
Economic efficiency calculation Tim-Luca Schwarze (FhG IEE) tim.luca.schwarze@iee.fraunhofer.de
Empirical surveys Johanna Holzberg (University of Kassel) holzberg@uni-kassel.de
Agent-based modeling Sascha Holzhauer (University of Kassel) Sascha.Holzhauer@uni-kassel.de
Practice partner municipality Sam Warmke (LH Kiel) Sam.Warmke@kiel.de

Publications

2025Kaiser, A., Voigtländer, L., & Cadenbach, A. M. (2025). Real-time visualization to optimize stakeholder decision-making in heating planning on a district level. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 3140, 042007. https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-6596/3140/4/042007
2025Holzhauer, S. (2025). WAERMER: Waermewende im urbanen Gebäudebestand mit Hilfe interaktiver Entscheidungsraumanalyse: Model Validation Workshop: Concept and Results. Kassel. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.16792148
2025Holzhauer, S., Digel, I., & Krebs, F. (2025). Deliverable 4.1: Prototypisches agentenbasierten Modell zu Wärmetechnologie- Investitionsentscheidungen kommunaler Hauseigentümer (S. TBD). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.15850534
2025Holzhauer, S. (2025). WAERMER - Waermewende im urbanen Gebäudebestand mit Hilfe iteraktiver Entscheidungsraumanalyse: Zusammenfassung des energiepolitischen und gesellschaftlichen Umfeldes in den Jahren 2022 bis 2025. Kassel. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17640132
2025Kaiser, A., Cadenbach, A. M., & Krebs, F. (2025). Stakeholder-informed multi-criteria decision-making for sustainable heat supply. International Journal of Sustainable Energy Planning and Management, 47, 104–118. https://doi.org/10.54337/ijsepm.9698
2023Digel, I., Holzhauer, S., & Krebs, F. (2023). Exploring Investment Decisions in Home Heating System Replacement with a Multi-stage Algorithm: An Agent-Based Model. In C. Elsenbroich & H. Verhagen (Hrsg.), Advances in Social Simulation : Proceedings of the 18th Social Simulation Conference, Glasgow, UK, 4-8 September 2023 (S. 137–149). Cham: Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-57785-7_12
2023Holzhauer, S., Krebs, F., & Jansen, L. (2023). Dynamics of Individual Investments in Heating Technology. In F. Squazzoni (Hrsg.), Advances in Social Simulation (S. 489–497). Cham: Springer Nature. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-34920-1_39

Lectures

2025Never change a running system? What hinders homeowners to replace their fossil-based heating systems with more environmentally friendly ones
Holzberg, Johanna; Ernst, Andreas
International Conference on Environmental Psychology 2025, Vilnius
2025Real-time visualization to optimize stakeholder decision-making in heat supply planning on a district level
Kaiser, Alwina
International Scientific Conference on the Built Environment in Transition - CISBAT 2025, Lausanne, Switzerland
2024An agent-based framework for modelling linked decisions
Holzhauer, Sascha
Social Simulation Conference 2024, Krakau
2024Examining the willingness to adopt new heating systems of German homeowners
Holzberg, Johanna; Ernst, Andreas
53. DGPs (Deutsche Gesellschaft für Psychologie) Kongress 2024, Wien (online)
2024Bridging the implementation gaps in the heat transition: a multi-criteria decision support approach for enhancing municipal heat supply and social acceptance
Kaiser, Alwina
10th International Conference on Smart Energy Systems 2024, Aalborg, Denmark
Federal Ministry of Economic Affairs and Climate Action